Craft burger review: New branch lands in Gosforth and we’re still obsessed

New Yorker burger from Craft Burger, stacked with onion rings, mustard, and a juicy beef patty

By Ania Askwith


Your friends might love this too – share it!

Unit 29 The Bait Room, Bakers Yard, Gosforth, Newcastle NE3 1XD

116 Ocean Road, South Shields NE33 2JF


Best for: burgers, shakes, desserts, Newcaste takeaway, South Shields dining

They say it’s ‘crafted to perfection’ and I couldn’t agree more.

We’ve been visiting the South Shields Craft Burger branch for a while now and love it every single time – everything is always sooo good.

Our regurlar order at Craft Burger:

  • Fish squared – a fish fillet burger (I get it  with extra gherkins and halloumi sticks); I always go for this and it never disappoints!
Advertisements
Fish Squared burger with halloumi sticks and extra gherkins served at Craft Burger South Shields.
Fish Squared Burger at Craft Burger, South Shields
  • The remix – the classic with 2 fried chicken tenders. It is huge and it is delish!
Advertisements
A vibrant table full of Craft Burger favourites at the Gosforth venue — featuring the Cheetos Smash Burger, New Yorker Boss Box, loaded chilli fries, Tayta tots, buffalo hot tenders, and house dips, all set against the fun, modern interior of the new branch.
Craft Burger, South Shields
  • Tayta tots – little hash brown balls, just delightful
Advertisements
A vibrant table full of Craft Burger favourites at the Gosforth venue — featuring the Cheetos Smash Burger, New Yorker Boss Box, loaded chilli fries, Tayta tots, buffalo hot tenders, and house dips, all set against the fun, modern interior of the new branch.
Craft Burger, South Shields
  • Skin on fries – they’re that perfect not too skinny and not too thick size, I always get them when we visit
  • Loaded fries -with loads of topping options to choose from
A vibrant table full of Craft Burger favourites at the Gosforth venue — featuring the Cheetos Smash Burger, New Yorker Boss Box, loaded chilli fries, Tayta tots, buffalo hot tenders, and house dips, all set against the fun, modern interior of the new branch.
Craft Burger, South Shields

The sweet side of Craft Burger

But Craft Burger is also known for their desserts, so of course we never skip that!

  • Snickers milkshake (unreal!)
Advertisements
Creamy Snickers milkshake topped with whipped cream and chocolate drizzle at Craft Burger South Shields.
Snickers Milkshake at Craft Burger, South Shields
  • The most amazing brownies – a Ferrero one and a Snickers one are our usual go tos.
Advertisements
Gooey chocolate brownie topped with Ferrero Rocher and melted chocolate from Craft Burger South Shields.
Brownie at Craft Burger, South Shields
  • Signature stack pancakes with Ferrero Rocher, Kinder Bueno layered with melted milk chocolate, finished with white & chocolate curls and mixed nuts – I’ve had these a few times and I think you need to try it for yourself (although having checked their menu – thee might have been discontinued…hopefully will return!)
Advertisements
Craft Burger’s American Dream waffle and Ferrero Kinder pancakes loaded with chocolate and toppings.
Waffle and Pancakes Dessert Duo at Craft Burger, South Shields
  • American dream waffle – Reese’s, Hershey’s & M&M’s peanuts drizzled with melted white & milk chocolate & rainbow sprinkles – as good as it sounds. Just moreish and delicious!
Craft Burger’s American Dream waffle and Ferrero Kinder pancakes loaded with chocolate and toppings.
Waffle and Pancakes at Craft Burger, South Shields
  • I love how they just go OTT with the toppings – you get so much of the sweet goodness. Honestly the perfect way to finish a delicious burger meal!
Advertisements
Assortment of decadent desserts including Ferrero Rocher and Snickers brownies, signature stack pancakes, and American Dream waffle at Craft Burger South Shields.
Desserts at Craft Burger South Shields

New branch, same delicious vibe

We usually visit the South Shields branch, but they’ve also got branches in Sunderland and Middlesbrough. And their most recent addition in Gosforth is super cute too – it’s a lovely new venue but it’s unmistakenly Craft Burger – with the fun decor and chill vibe. And of course the same delicious taste.

Advertisements
Full table spread of Craft Burger food at the Gosforth branch including burgers, loaded fries, tenders, tots, dips, and drinks.
Craft Burger, Gosforth

What we tried this time

We actually went on 28 May – the national burger day (what a way to celebrate, right!)

This time we decided to switch things up… a little.

Cheetos smash

This one takes the classic smash burger up a notch with a generous crumbling of American Cheetos. The Cheetos add such good texture, and of course it makes the burger even more delish. We asked for extra gherkins too – the sharpness cuts through the richness perfectly. It’s just stunning.

Advertisements
Cheetos Smash Burger from Craft Burger Gosforth topped with crispy American Cheetos and extra gherkins.
Cheetos Smash Burger at Craft Burger, Gosforth

House chilli dip

Ideal for a bit of heat on the side. Not overpowering, just a satisfying chilli kick that goes great with fries, tenders or even dunking your burger (so so good)

Cheetos Smash Burger held above the table with loaded fries, buffalo tenders, and sides visible below.
Cheetos Smash Burger at Craft Burger, Gosforth

Skin on fries

Crispy on the outside, fluffy on the inside. You can ask for them plain, but I love their seasoning.

Advertisements
Full table spread of Craft Burger food at the Gosforth branch including burgers, loaded fries, tenders, tots, dips, and drinks.
Craft Burger, Gosforth

Tayta tots

Little golden hash brown style bites – crunchy on the outside and soft inside. Perfect for dipping or just picking at between bites. Although I just eat them straight from the box, before I even think about my burger. I may be addicted…

Crispy Tayta Tots and seasoned skin-on fries from Craft Burger Gosforth.
Tayta Tots at Craft Burger, Gosforth

Boss box – New Yorker burger

A hearty pick that doesn’t mess about. You get to choose your burger – we went with the New Yorker – which is stacked high with onion rings and mustard. GOOD.

Advertisements
Full table spread of Craft Burger food at the Gosforth branch including burgers, loaded fries, tenders, tots, dips, and drinks.
Craft Burger, Gosforth

Loaded fries – we opted for chilli.

This could easily be a full on meal. Messy in the best way and super tasty.

Buffalo hot sauce tenders

Three crispy tenders coated in zingy buffalo hot sauce. They’ve got heat, so best to order some milder sauce too for a bit of balance.

Advertisements
Spicy Buffalo chicken tenders with chipotle dipping sauce from Craft Burger Gosforth.
Crispy chicken tenders at Craft Burger, Gosforth

Chipotle sauce tub

Smoky, creamy and ideal for dipping those tots, tenders or fries. Great if you get anything buffalo hot as it’s a nice hot/mild flavour combo between the two.

The best chocolate cake you can buy

And of course, we couldn’t leave without dessert…

Matilda cake. Honestly, there is nothing else like it. It’s chocolatey, gooey, moreish – literally the best chocolate cake I’ve ever had. You just have to try it.

Advertisements
Rich and gooey Matilda chocolate cake slice with layers of thick frosting from Craft Burger.
Matilda Cake from Craft Burger, Gosforth

Why Craft Burger is one of our favourite burger places – ever

We honestly can’t stay away from this place. The burgers are delish, the sides are next level, and the desserts are ridiculously good. And I am not usually even a dessert person!

Locations:

Craft Burger have a few locations:

  • 116 Ocean Road, South Shields NE33 2JF
  • Unit 29 The Bait Room, Bakers Yard, Gosforth, Newcastle NE3 1XD
  • Also in Sunderland and Middlesbrough
A vibrant table full of Craft Burger favourites at the Gosforth venue — featuring the Cheetos Smash Burger, New Yorker Boss Box, loaded chilli fries, Tayta tots, buffalo hot tenders, and house dips, all set against the fun, modern interior of the new branch.
Craft Burger, South Shields

Tips for visiting:

  • There’s loads of options to personalise your meal; e.g. you can choose up to 2 extra toppings which are free, from a selection of gherkins, onions, peppers etc
  • There are a few branches, so you’ll likely find one near you
  • Their desserts are some of a – definitely a must try
  • Their delish Matilda cake is also sold at Spud Life on Chillingham Road
  • If unsure what to have, their Boss box is a great value and you get a good selection of their burgers and sides.
Advertisements
A vibrant table full of Craft Burger favourites at the Gosforth venue — featuring the Cheetos Smash Burger, New Yorker Boss Box, loaded chilli fries, Tayta tots, buffalo hot tenders, and house dips, all set against the fun, modern interior of the new branch.
Craft Burger, South Shields

Sign up for free and get the latest news from Magpie and Mash sent direct to you

Advertisements
Stacked gourmet burger with fries at Burger Drop Newcastle
The Remix at Burger Drop, Wallsend

Link

For updates, special offers, upcoming events, and a peek behind the scenes visit their website here or follow them on their socials here.

Stacked gourmet burger with fries at Burger Drop Newcastle
The Oklahoma at Burger Drop, Wallsend

Reviews

For reviews, ratings, real customer experiences, and to see what people are saying – check out their Tripadvisor reviews here.

Advertisements
Stacked gourmet burger with fries at Burger Drop Newcastle
The Oklahoma at Burger Drop, Wallsend

Enjoyed this post? 

If you love discovering things to do, places to go, and the best spots to eat and drink in the North East and beyond, be sure to follow my blog for more reviews, recommendations, travel tips, and hidden gems. And for a closer look at my day-to-day experiences, follow me on Instagram @ania.askwith for behind-the-scenes content and even more discoveries! Let’s explore together!


Magpie and Mash, a blog about food and drink, things to do and travel in the north east of england

You may also like



Leave a comment